Who Are The Zizians? with Andy Ngo

12 November 2026

With Andy Ngo

North America

Journalist Andy Ngo talks to Stella O'Malley and Bret Alderman about the Zizians, a trans-identifying group he links to murders in the US. For British listeners, the case lands as a warning rather than a headline: it shows what happens when gender-identity claims go unquestioned by institutions, echoing exactly the caution the Cass Review urged on the NHS. As Tavistock's successor clinics operate under tighter safeguarding rules, this episode asks what duty of care means when ideology, not evidence, drives decisions - a question British clinicians, schools and policymakers are still working through.

Andy Ngo, the journalist best known for his reporting on Portland's Antifa and BLM riots, joins Stella O'Malley and Bret Alderman this week to talk about his new book, The Zizians: Inside a Trans Death Cult. Ngo traces how a loose, trans-identifying, vegan-linked group he calls the Zizians emerged from Silicon Valley's rationalist and effective altruism scene - circles preoccupied with AI existential risk - and became entangled, he argues, in a series of murder and attempted murder cases across the United States still working through American courts. The central figure, Ngo says, is Jack Amadeus LaSota, known as Ziz, who moved to the Bay Area in 2016 and drew others into an increasingly isolated worldview. For listeners used to Beyond Gender's usual territory - gender clinics, detransition stories, school policy - this episode is a departure into true crime, but the questions it raises are familiar ones: what happens when a community's identity claims are accepted without challenge, and what responsibility institutions and movements bear when that acceptance curdles into something dangerous. None of this happened in Britain, and nothing here should be read as a comment on NHS gender services or British trans people generally. But the underlying dynamic - unexamined affirmation substituting for proper inquiry - is exactly what the Cass Review spent years warning against in a far more mundane setting: paediatric gender clinics. Dr Hilary Cass found that the old Tavistock model let ideology stand in for evidence, with clinicians reluctant to ask hard questions for fear of being labelled transphobic. The Zizians case, however extreme and far away, is a reminder of where that same reluctance to scrutinise can lead when nobody is willing to challenge it. That matters for Britain's current settlement. NHS England has closed the Tavistock's gender service and rebuilt provision around regional centres with more caution, more psychological assessment and a presumption against early medical intervention for most young people. Schools, too, are working under revised guidance urging staff not to simply affirm a child's stated identity without involving parents and considering the wider picture. The Zizians story, as Ngo tells it, is an extreme American endpoint of a much more common pattern: communities, online and offline, that reward identity claims with belonging and punish doubt. For a podcast built around psychotherapy, evidence and open debate, hosted from Ireland but followed closely by British clinicians, teachers and parents, the conversation underlines why Genspect and allied groups keep pressing for scrutiny over slogans. Ngo's reporting career, forged covering Antifa and street violence, gives him a particular eye for how fringe ideas move from online subcultures into real-world harm - a lesson British institutions, still absorbing the Cass Review's findings, are arguably still learning themselves.

More episodes about the UK